WINDPOWER 2012 Update: Transmission for wind in western U.S.: Lower cost, lower variability

Adding the next 11,000 megawatts (MW) of wind generating capacity to the western U.S. could be done in such a way as to reduce both wholesale costs and utility system variability, according to Lawrence Willick of LS Power.

Willick, one of the speakers at the WINDPOWER 2012 session "Operation Transmission: Plugging Wind into America," said the Western Renewable Energy Zone study published in 2009 had pegged wind potential of the western states at 95,000 MW, well above the 14,000 MW currently installed in the region.  "The question is, what's the next step?," he added.

The CREZ Transmission Optimization Study, conducted in conjunction with the Competitive Renewable Energy Zone program in Texas, provided the technical basis for a substantial expansion of wind capacity in that state, Willick said, and a similar effort is needed in the West. He added, "What I hope to do is to provide some direction on what such a study might involve."

There are two main barriers to the development of more wind in the region, he said–lack of transmission capacity and utility integration issues. The existing wind generation has been developed around the existing grid, and there's not a lot of additional transmission capacity available. Also, "some balancing areas claim they are saturated with wind … The perception is, more wind will mean much higher integration costs," Willick said, adding, "People are looking to minimize energy, integration, and transmission costs.  The way to balance those goals and get to the next increment is three words: diversity, diversity, diversity."

A video display, produced by the Midwest Independent System Operator (MISO) of wind patterns across the Upper Midwest illustrates the importance of diversifying the location of wind generation, he said–wind speeds follow weather systems and are constantly fluctuating, rising in some parts of the region and falling in others.

Analysis of data gathered for the National Renewable Energy Laboratory's (NREL) 2010 Western Wind and Solar Integration Study, Willick said, makes the importance of geographic diversification very clear.  The WWSIS found that when new wind and solar installations were added at a variety of locations, utility system variation actually decreased below normal levels caused by changes in demand throughout the day.

Similar results, Willick said, came from looking at two scenarios for new wind installation, one with five sites and one with 17.  In both cases, the total variability was well below the variability at individual wind sites. Benefits of diversifying include more efficient use of transmission resources and reduced integration costs, he said, and further, the 17-site scenario could be accomplished without adding new transmission lines to those already proposed for the region.

Related articles:

Fact check: Elliott off target on wind and cost savings, June 4, 2012
Fact check: Coverage of Argonne wind and emissions study flawed, June 1, 2012
Fact check: Bell missteps on utility integration of wind power, May 24, 2012
New study: Wind power can save Midwestern consumers between $3 billion and $9.5 billion annually by 2020, May 23, 2012
Wind generation sets new records in Texas, Spain, May 22, 2012
Fact check: Silverstein errs on wind's variability, emissions cuts, February 27, 2012
Fact check: Pavlak errs on wind integration, February 14, 2012
Across the U.S., wind power sets new generation records, February 13, 2012
More savings for ratepayers in Southeast as Louisiana utility ups wind purchases, January 26, 2012
Fact check: New Dutch report misinformed on wind power and emissions, January 13, 2012
Xcel sets world record with 55.6% wind penetration, November 28, 2011
Wind research generates savings for large utility, November 14, 2011
Xcel Energy: More wind, less cost, October 31, 2011
More wind power and utility integration: A question already being resolved, October 19, 2011
After a scorching week, wind power lessons from the Texas heat wave, August 11, 2011
Wind energy integration: Some fundamental facts, June 23, 2011