Researcher: Claim that offshore wind causes beached whales 'bad reporting'

I saw it on Twitter (which, by the way, could use a good fact checker, dream on) a few days ago–something about offshore wind farms in Europe causing whales to beach themselves. Like many anti-wind claims, it seemed farfetched–whales have been beaching themselves in recent years in many locations that are nowhere near offshore wind farms–so I didn't pay too much attention.

It turns out that the original source of the report, the United Kingdom Daily Telegraph newspaper (a frequent critic of wind power) issued a correction two days after it published the March 15 article, but other outlets forwarded the false information along, including Newsweek magazine, which included it in a short wind-bashing piece in its March 20 issue.

The media watchdog group Media Matters has the story in a nice analysis piece, which deconstructs the whale fable along with (1) the misimpression that wind power poses a threat to birds in general and (2) the fabrication that it doesn't reduce emissions from electricity generation.

One of the whale study's co-authors, in an e-mail to Media Matters, commented, “No one is saying that there won't be any potential disturbance from the installation or operation of wind farms – I personally think that is likely as well at least in terms of temporary responses during construction … [b]ut to suggest that our results indicate marine mammals are stranded by windfarms is just erroneous and bad reporting.”

Stay informed

Take Action

Subscribe to the American Clean Power blog and receive the latest renewable energy news, policy updates, and opportunities to get involved.